Friday, May 25, 2012

\m/

Okay, so this entry is meant to compare two songs that are... well, the description gets so general, I guess it's just to compare two songs. I was thinking of comparing some song I know of that are totally unrelated but have uncannily similar melodies, but the songs I'm thinking of are triplets, not twins. Still, I'm posting them. I just won't be analyzing them.

Observe:

Bon Jovi - You Give Love a Bad Name

Nightwish - Where were You Last Night

Sabaton - White Death

I really like all three songs, especially White Death, but it just bugs me how similar they are. I ran across a fourth one of these once, but I don't remember what it was.


Anyway, analysis. I've decided to compare two Nightwish songs. Yes, I like Nightwish a nice damn lot. The song above featured a different lead (female) singer from the singer in the two following songs. The two songs I'll be comparing are both from the most recent Nightwish album, Imaginaerum. I happen to have that particular CD right here, too. All the more reason to use these two songs:

Nightwish - Storytime

Nightwish - Ghost River

Here's what I came up with on my "Listening Framework" sheet:


Listening Framework
(SIMPLIFIED)

Listening Phase 1 (Rhythm)

Tempo [slow, medium, fast]

Allegretto

Source [where is the rhythm coming from?]

Background strings in early intro, then drums for most of song.


Groove [describe how the personality of the rhythm]

Dark, flowing, energetic

Listening Phase 2 (Arrangement)

Instrumentation [which instruments drive the song?]
Distorted electric guitar and lead vocals make up most of song, followed by backup vocals, piano, and strings. Finally, accents are made by bells (misc. percussion) timpani, and brass.

Structure/Organization [how is the song built? Order, patterns, etc.]

Intro, chorus, verse, chorus, instrumental section, chorus, stronger chorus.


Emotional Architecture [Draw how the song build and drop?]


______
__ ///---------____----------//\\ ___-------//
--^--^--/// \\---// \\___---////

Listening Phase 3 (Sound Quality)

Balance

  • Height [high and low of frequency]

Lots. Low pitch brass, timpani; mid pitch guitar, strings; High pitch vocals, guitar, bells

  • Width [stereo panning left/right]
    Not much panning, vocals and lead guitar are front and center, backing vocals/orchestra kept to either side, to the back.

  • Depth [layers of instruments - via loudness]
    A lot of depth, features an orchestra/choir
Listening Framework
(SIMPLIFIED)

Listening Phase 1 (Rhythm)

Tempo [slow, medium, fast]

allegretto

Source [where is the rhythm coming from?]

Drums, brass when drums are not present.

Groove [describe how the personality of the rhythm]

Poppy sometimes, heavy and violent others.

Listening Phase 2 (Arrangement)

Instrumentation [which instruments drive the song?]

Lead vocals (male and female), electric guitars consistently lead, sometimes give up lead to trumpets/brass. Strings are consistently backing. Children's choir takes over once, backs other times. Least common is occasional percussion.

Structure/Organization [how is the song built? Order, patterns, etc.]

Short intro, chorus, verse, chorus, instrumental, chorus, choir chorus (it makes sense), instrumental, chorus.


Emotional Architecture [Draw how the song build and drop?]


___ ----
____ -^--^--^--------__ -^--^--^------- \/ -------- ----
-^-^--^-^-/ \______/ \\_____/ \--/\__/

Listening Phase 3 (Sound Quality)

Balance

  • Height [high and low of frequency]
Not very high, low and medium frequencies from guitars, male vocals, occasional high from female vocals


  • Width [stereo panning left/right]
Not really panning. Orchestra in back, guitars and lead vocals in front.


  • Depth [layers of instruments - via loudness]
      1. A lot of depth, blasting vocals, guitar, and brass interrupting quieter parts.

As I feared, my emotional architecture didn't really make it. Still, you can see the general shape of each. They're both sort of similar in that sense. However, Ghost River has a number of emotional spikes where it suddenly brings in a bit of loud guitar or particularly nasty male vocals. After mapping the emotional architecture for both of these songs, I find the concept of graphing pure emotion as I did just now leaves a lot of information out of the emotional analysis. Especially in the case of these two songs, the raw emotion of the two songs resemble each other despite inspiring drastically different emotions.

The Rhythm and instrumentation of Storytime is very similar to that of Ghost River, which is the primary reason for the similar curves, but when I hear Storytime, I just get... happy! The images invoked by the lyrics, mixed with the fantastic, even optimistic melodies make for a very different experience from the aggressive vocals and dark lyrics you get from Ghost River.

The energy behind Ghost River is one of the main reasons metal is by far my favorite genre of music, but it doesn't “feel” anything like Storytime. To make a more meaningful emotional model of a song, I think it makes sense to graph the change of each separate emotion over the duration of the song (although I'm not going to do that).


Looking back at some more of the similarities between the two, I notice that both songs follow a sort of commercial pattern. Chorus, verse, chorus, verse, chorus, etc. This actually made me sort of sad to think about, but then I realized that the consistent pattern to both songs didn't take away from what I really like about Nightwish. What I love to hear in both Storytime and Ghost River is the mix of poppy female vocals, growling male vocals, choruses, electric rock guitars, and an entire orchestra.

When all of those diverse elements can converge into this type of music, it makes me feel like I'm listening to something truly epic that other artists can't offer. I mentioned earlier that metal is my favorite genre, but to get more specific, my absolute favorite genre of music is symphonic metal, and that's exactly what you get, in two different emotional flavors from Storytime and Ghost River.




No comments:

Post a Comment